Structural Discrimination: Does Ban The Box Help or Hurt This Cause?

One of the trendiest phrases in fair hiring discussions is ‘structural discrimination.’ Its validity is somewhat similar to ‘disparate impact,’ a bit murky and debatable; nonetheless its popularity is gaining.

All of Us or None, the non-profit agency who credits itself with coining ‘Ban The Box,’ uses structural discrimination as its leading reason to eliminate questions about criminal convictions on employment applications. So far, nine states and more than 50 municipalities recognize Ban The Box reforms. In the first three months of 2014, 11 cities and counties across the nation adopted these policies emphasizing an applicant’s qualifications rather than his or her past mistakes, such as Louisville, New Orleans, and Indianapolis.

The definition of structural discrimination isn’t found on the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) website and it is used only in passing on the National Employment Law Project website. Where we do find it after extensive research, is on a website from New Zealand:

             “Structural discrimination (also referred to as indirect discrimination or institutional racism) refers to practices, norms and behaviours within institutions and social structures which have the effect of denying rights or opportunities to members of minority groups, keeping them from achieving the same opportunities available to the majority group. Structural discrimination can occur both intentionally and unintentionally. The term is also used in relation to more informal practices which have become embedded in everyday organisational life and effectively become part of the system, “how we do things around here.””

Ban The Box advocates argue structural discrimination exists when employers don’t allow applicants to reach the next step in the employment process (whatever that may be) because they checked ‘yes’ to a question about previous criminal convictions. Since the question is included on nearly every job application (except those states with Ban The Box laws) some people argue that structural discrimination is pervasive. They also say that it disproportionately affects some minorities because African Americans and Latinos/Hispanics are convicted of crimes at higher rates than other races.

There are still plenty questions, however, surrounding the necessity for, and validity of, Ban The Box movements as the benchmark for eliminating so-called structural discrimination. Employers, especially small businesses who don’t have HR departments or staffers, feel a question about criminal convictions is important to ask to avoid workplace safety issues, which we know leaves employers open to liability lawsuits. Furthermore, some employers feel pressure from Ban The Box advocates and the changing law landscape to eliminate background checks altogether. This is clearly not advisable for a number of reasons:

Q: Most laws like these don’t prohibit employers from running a background check so why is it important to eliminate a question about criminal convictions or arrests if it’s going to come up at some point in the hiring process anyway?

A: The idea is for all candidates to be judged on their qualifications first. Then, if a background check turns something up that an employer has questions about, they will be held to EEOC Guidance standards and compliance laws in how to handle the information. The hope is that employers will then ask the candidate about the arrest or conviction and take into consideration if it was/is job-related, how long it has been since it happened, and what they’ve been doing since.

Q: Some research has suggested that some employers make incorrect assumptions that most African American and Latino men have conviction histories, and that Ban The Box has nothing to do with structural discrimination. In fact, some people argue that laws like Ban The Box could have the reverse effect they were intended for – that more employers would use race or ethnicity as a proxy criminal history. Is this true?

A: In either of those proposed scenarios, discrimination is happening. So why not take any step we can to begin to eliminate it? Dealing with intentional discrimination by allowing disparate impact won’t work.

Q: Why is it hard for some businesses to simply eliminate this question from their applications?

A: There is a several reasons. One, many small businesses don’t have a dedicated Human Resource professional and already find it hard to keep up with all the changing employment laws. Don’t forget, there aren’t just federal laws to comply with but state and local laws. It’s a lot. Two, criminal record checks provide a necessary and very important component to the fair hiring process. They keep workplace safety a top priority and are used to treat everyone equally because they are used as part of a standard hiring protocol so it’s impossible to say that someone was treated different if everyone is given a background check and compliance laws are followed. Three, there are certain industries like child care and health care and transportation where it’s required by law to conduct criminal background checks. We don’t ever want this compromised by a one-size-fits-all policy like Ban The Box.

Do you have more questions about Ban The Box and how it could affect hiring procedures or structural discrimination? Send them our way and we’ll do our best to get you an answer!

This entry was posted in General and tagged , , , , by Patricia Carlson. Bookmark the permalink.

Patricia Carlson is a content writer who specializes in B2C and B2B inbound marketing. She blogs regularly for clients about the background screening and finance industries, and generates newsletters, white papers and email campaigns for a variety of businesses. Patricia also produces a heavy rotation of editorial material for home design, law enforcement, and family magazines. She’s been writing professionally for more than a dozen years, and for Active Screening for more than two of those. Check out LinkedIn for a roster of Patricia's clients and links to published works. When she’s not interviewing sources or researching trends, she’s living a fast-paced Florida life questioning the antics of her two young children, partner and mischievous cat. Patricia loves to talk tennis and TV on Twitter - give her a shout @pattycfreelance.
Active ScreeningBarbara S.
Healthcare Industry

"Here at Holland Hospital, we have been extremely pleased with Active Screening. The report results come back quickly, usually within 24 hours or less.  The staff at Active Screening is easy accessible, knowledgeable and responds to our questions promptly."

Active ScreeningLynn C. Staffing Industry

"Benton Mobley has been and remains my Main point of contact at Active Screening from the beginning; so aside from the comfort of dealing with the same person all these years, there is the most important fact of all;  customer satisfaction. Benton knows the business like the back of his hand; and that is what we need in our fast paced industry of staffing. He is the all-time BEST!  MY employer, Leslie, believes in the notion that great service deserves to be rewarded, so we are here for the duration.We get immediate and personalized attention for any and all concerns we need addressed, and in the staffing industry, this is vital."

Active ScreeningCayce R. Education Industry

"My experience working with Active Screening for our background check process has been very positive.  The reports are almost always completed in a very timely fashion. The information reported appears to be very thorough and accurate.  On the rare occasions that we have questions or problems, the customer service team is always very quick to respond and resolve the issue.  Overall, I am very pleased with the service I receive from Active Screening."

Active ScreeningCraig H. Staffing Industry

"Your customer service is excellent.  The turn around time on background checks is quite fast.  Excellent work.  I haven't had a single problem."

Active ScreeningJackie C. Education Industry

"I wanted to thank you and your staff for being so patient and working so diligently with the Human Resources staff during our recent endeavor to process all of our work study students through background screenings.  We have never had to process so many requests within such a short period of time before, but thanks to you and your staff we made it. Again thank you, we made a good choice in selecting Active Screening."

Active ScreeningLindsey W.  Financial Industry

"I wanted to share my appreciation for your wonderful service...switching background screening companies could have been a stressful task, but your company made the transition seamless. Your website was extremely easy to navigate and the turn around time has been great. I appreciate when information is missing or entered incorrectly during ordering, your company notifies me right away to ensure that my error does not hold the reports results, causing us a delay in hiring an individual...Active Screening has been great to us and I would definitely refer them to others."

Active ScreeningTerry S. Property Management

"Working with Active Screening over the last year and half has been a wonderful experience. They deliver fast and informative results at the best price. Their level of professionalism and the speed they respond to our issues is a benefit that any company can value from. I would highly recommend using Active Screening and their amazing team."

Active ScreeningYulesis D.  Staffing Industry

“Interactive Response Technologies (IRT) has more than 2,000 employees at multiple locations across the United States. IRT has been using Active Screening to conduct criminal background checks since 2006. During this time, Active Screening has consistently returned accurate reports, usually with less than 48 hours turnaround. If there are any problems or inconsistencies with the reports, their staff has called to notify us so that we can attempt to rectify the situation. The staff at Active Screening is always courteous and congenial over the phone. In our opinion, Active Screening is outstanding.”

Active ScreeningAndy N. Software Provider

 "Active Screening has helped us screen our applicants in record time for more than two years.... we are very impressed with the professionalism and speed with which their service team responds to our questions. They understand our needs and are a pleasure to work with. I highly recommend them."

Active ScreeningCassie J. Staffing Industry

"The Active Screening team is very informative; they provided a complete consultation on all the services, so I understood what I needed, and saved me hours and hours of my time learning the various services. Their reputation, as being on the cutting edge of employment screening best practices, certainly held true in this instance. The expertise they brought to the table was invaluable to our understanding of our applicants backgrounds. I highly recommend Active Screening to anyone with the task of screening large numbers of applicants and needing reliable customer support."

Active Screening

With over 20 years of law enforcement experience I can attest to the fact that the strongest predictor of future criminal behavior is a person’s criminal history. As the manager of campus safety at my church, I depend on Active Screening to provide a thorough assessment of every criminal history background check we request. For more than 3 years, Active Screening has been faithful to this task with timely, accurate and reliable service.

Active Screening

We have benefited from knowing that we are not exposing the communities we work with or ourselves to unnecessary risk. We continue to have a perfect record in that we have never had a serious incident with a trip participant causing harm or acting inappropriately with any community member or fellow team member- thank goodness!

Active Screening

I would highly recommend any association or organization who conducts background checks to use Active Screening. In addition to my involvement with WAHA, I am an officer in a corporation with over 500 employees who provide treatment, mental health, and correctional services for children and adolescents. Our company is mandated by law to do comprehensive background searches and I can say with the utmost sincerity that Active Screening product rivals that of any government or other private sector process.

Active Screening

We have used Active Screening and their solution VERITY to screen all our coaches and volunteers working with youth. The online system gives us an easy and cost-effective solution to collecting forms and payments from our applicants...and we simply login to view the results of who passed or failed. It's so easy....thank you Active Screening.